Sometimes, a romance feels inevitable, as if the universe keeps pulling two people back together. Hollywood romances often rely on the formula of “Guy Gets Girl, Guy Loses Girl, Guy Gets Girl Back”, but the most memorable love stories often repeat this cycle many times, with no promise of a happy ending.
The five-year love story between Charlie (Nick Robinson) and Harper (Emilia Jones) in “Charlie Harper” is nothing short of cyclical. What begins as a high school crush, fueled by trading CDs of favorite songs, rekindles at a college party where music once again bridges the gap. That spark leads them to New Orleans, where Harper chases her culinary dreams, while Charlie’s lack of ambition and struggles with substance abuse drive a wedge between them. Life separates them, but fate orchestrates another chance encounter, proving that some emotions never fade.
Written by Tom Dean and co-directed with Mac Eldridge, “Charlie Harper” unfolds in a nonlinear narrative, showing the couple’s three major reunions early on. This structure emphasizes the inevitability of their connection, no matter how circumstances evolve. The film portrays their magnetic chemistry, but also the flaws: he’s the classic “I Can Fix Him” archetype, handsome yet self-destructive, while she’s an ambitious dreamer destined for greatness in the culinary world. Their contrasting drives create a romance that is both intense and doomed.
Dean and Eldridge craft a visually stylish film that plays heavily on nostalgia and emotion. Viewers will likely shed tears at its Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) premiere, especially younger audiences seeking a modern indie love story reminiscent of “(500) Days of Summer.” However, seasoned filmgoers may find its dependence on clichés—from nostalgic mixtapes to bittersweet hometown escapes—somewhat predictable.
See More ...
Despite its flaws, “Charlie Harper” resonates in the moment. The chemistry between Robinson and Jones, the authentic emotional beats, and the exploration of how toxic young romances shape adulthood ensure its impact lingers as you leave the theater. While its lack of originality may limit its rewatch value, the film succeeds in making audiences feel the timeless truth: even when love isn’t enough, it shapes us forever.
“Charlie Harper” premiered at the 2025 Toronto International Film Festival and is currently seeking U.S. distribution.
